Where Did They Film The New Fantasy Island

Ever watched the new Fantasy Island and thought, "Wow, that's... pretty?" Like, seriously pretty?
I have a confession. I'm obsessed. But not just with the drama (oh, the drama!). It's the scenery! Where IS this magical place?
Let's Play Detective!
Okay, first thought: Somewhere tropical, obviously. Duh! Palm trees? Check. Turquoise water? Check. Enough sunshine to make a vampire spontaneously combust? Double-check.
Must Read
But specifically where? That's the million-dollar question, isn't it? You could spend hours on Google Images, trust me, I nearly have.
Some say Puerto Rico. Others whisper about Hawaii. My grandma thinks it's all filmed on a sound stage. Bless her heart.
The Official Answer (According to the Internet)
Apparently, the show mostly filmed in Puerto Rico. Specifically, around San Juan and Fajardo. See? Google doesn't lie...usually.

They even used some fancy resorts for the "Fantasy Island" hotel. Talk about living the dream! Imagine accidentally wandering onto a TV set during your vacation.
That would be awkward. But awesome. Definitely awesome.
My Unpopular Opinion (Prepare for Controversy!)
Okay, here it comes. Deep breath.

While Puerto Rico is gorgeous (no shade, Puerto Rico!), part of me thinks they CGI-ed it up a bit. Just a tiny bit.
Hear me out! The beaches are too perfect. The sunsets are too vibrant. Even the palm trees seem suspiciously symmetrical.
Is it just me, or does it sometimes feel like a screensaver come to life? A very expensive, well-acted screensaver, granted.
The "Fantasy" in Fantasy Island
Maybe that's the point, though. It's Fantasy Island, right?

It's not supposed to be a gritty, realistic portrayal of island life. It's escapism! Pure, unadulterated, tropical escapism.
So, if they tweaked the colors a little. So what! It's television! We're all being manipulated anyway. (Just kidding... mostly.)
Perhaps they filmed some scenes on other islands, too? A little "B-roll" from the Dominican Republic? A sneaky shot of a Hawaiian volcano?

The world may never know! And honestly, I'm okay with that. It adds to the mystique.
In Conclusion (aka, Let's Book a Trip!)
Whether it's all Puerto Rico, a mix of islands, or a cleverly disguised sound stage, one thing is for sure. Fantasy Island makes me want to pack my bags.
Who wouldn't want to escape to a place where your wildest dreams (or darkest nightmares) come true? Just maybe bring extra sunscreen. And a good therapist.
And if you happen to stumble upon Mr. Rourke while you're there... tell him I said hi! And that I have a very interesting fantasy for him to consider.
