So You Think You Can Dance Season 1 Judges

So You Think You Can Judge? A Look Back at SYTYCD's Original Crew

Remember the good ol' days of So You Think You Can Dance? The tears, the triumphs, the totally awkward partnerings. But let's be honest, part of the magic was the OG judges.

They gave us critiques. They gave us sass. And sometimes, they made us scratch our heads in confusion.

The Queen Bee: Mia Michaels

Oh, Mia. You either loved her or…tolerated her. Her choreography was undeniably brilliant. But her judging style? Intense. Think demanding professor meets eccentric artist.

Must Read

I have a confession. As much as I sometimes rolled my eyes at her theatrics, I secretly lived for her dramatic pronouncements. "I want to lick your face!" remains an iconic, if slightly unsettling, piece of SYTYCD history.

Unpopular opinion alert: I think Mia's tough love was often exactly what those dancers needed. They cried, sure, but they also grew exponentially.

The Nice Guy: Nigel Lythgoe

Nigel. The Simon Cowell of dance, but with slightly less venom. He was the constant, the voice of reason (mostly). He knew his stuff, and he wasn't afraid to say it.

So You Think You Can Dance: All Judges, Ranked

Remember his iconic catchphrase, "From the top!"? It's permanently etched in my brain.

Another confession: Sometimes, I thought he played it a little too safe. I longed for him to unleash his inner Mia just once. Just to see what would happen.

The Broadway Star: Mary Murphy

Mary Murphy brought the energy. The screaming! The hot tamale train! She was pure, unadulterated joy, even when she was critiquing a particularly disastrous cha-cha.

All of the Guest Judges on 'So You Think You Can Dance' Since Season 1

Let's be real, did she always offer the most insightful commentary? Maybe not. But did she make the show infinitely more entertaining? Absolutely!

Don't hate me, but sometimes I fast-forwarded through the other judges' critiques just to get to Mary's. Her enthusiasm was infectious.

The Guest Judge Roulette

Part of the fun was the revolving door of guest judges. We saw everyone from choreographers to actors to pop stars. Some were amazing. Others were…less so.

So You Think You Can Dance Judge Matthew Morrison Departs: Details

Remember when Debbie Allen graced the stage? Pure class. And when Tyce Diorio came to critique? Get ready for some drama!

I'll say it: some of those guest judges were clearly just there for the exposure. They offered generic, platitude-filled comments that added nothing to the show. But hey, at least they looked good on camera, right?

The Verdict?

Looking back, the original SYTYCD judging panel was a perfect blend of talent, personality, and, let's face it, a little bit of crazy.

‘So You Think You Can Dance’ Judges: Who Left and Why

They weren't always right. They weren't always fair. But they were always entertaining. And that's what made the show so addictive.

So, raise your hand if you miss the days of Mia's face-licking declarations and Mary's hot tamale train! I know I do. They are the cornerstone of the show.

Maybe it’s time for a re-watch, just to relive the glory days of questionable critiques and unforgettable dance moves.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I'm off to practice my hot tamale train in the living room. Don't judge.