Do You Need To Watch Fullmetal Alchemist Before Brotherhood

Okay, let's talk Fullmetal Alchemist. More specifically, do you really need to watch the original before diving into Brotherhood?

Prepare yourselves. I'm about to say something potentially controversial. You might want to sit down.

Unpopular Opinion Incoming!

Here it comes: Nope! You probably don't need to.

Gasp! I know, I know. Some purists are clutching their alchemical circles right now.

But hear me out, please! Let's be reasonable.

The original Fullmetal Alchemist anime (from 2003) is fantastic, no doubt. It’s got a great vibe.

It deviates from the manga's storyline pretty significantly, though. It creates its own ending. Think of it as an alternate universe, FMA-style.

Brotherhood? It sticks much closer to the manga. It's the "canon" version for many fans.

So, essentially, you're getting two different stories. Both using the same characters and initial setup.

Now, some folks argue the 2003 version does character introductions better. It spends more time establishing the Elric brothers and their world.

Sure, that's a fair point! But is it essential? I'm not convinced.

Brotherhood is pretty efficient. It provides the necessary background information. It might be a little faster, granted.

Think of it like skipping the tutorial in a video game. You might miss a few minor tips. But you'll probably figure it out!

If you're short on time and eager to experience the complete manga storyline? Jump straight into Brotherhood!

You won’t be completely lost. I promise.

Plus, you'll have the delightful experience of watching an awesome series.

Then, if you really love the world of Amestris? Go back and explore the 2003 version. Treat it as a fascinating "what if?" scenario.

Okay, I'll address the counterarguments. Someone will say I'm missing the "emotional connection" built by the 2003 series.

I get it! Nostalgia is a powerful thing. But emotional connection varies from person to person.

Besides, Brotherhood isn't exactly devoid of feels. Prepare for waterworks, regardless of which you watch first.

And hey, more Edward Elric is never a bad thing, right?

Still unsure? Try this: watch the first few episodes of both series. See which one grabs you more!

It’s your anime journey, after all. You get to decide.

Don't let anyone tell you there's a "right" or "wrong" way to enjoy Fullmetal Alchemist.

So, there you have it. My bold, perhaps slightly insane, opinion.

You can absolutely enjoy Brotherhood without the original.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to hide from the angry mob wielding pitchforks and transmutation circles. Wish me luck!

Happy watching, fellow anime adventurers! May your alchemy always be successful (and not involve transmuting your dog).