Cast Of I Know What You Did Last Summer Series

Okay, let's talk I Know What You Did Last Summer. Not the movie, not the book, but the series! You know, the one that tried (and maybe sorta succeeded?) to capture that slasher vibe for a new generation.

The Core Four (ish)

First, we have Madison Iseman, rocking the dual role of Allison and Lennon. Talk about commitment! Unpopular opinion: I kinda preferred her as Lennon. Fight me.

Then there's Brianne Tju as Margot. Oh, Margot. She was the chaotic, morally ambiguous queen we didn't know we needed. I secretly wanted her to be the killer, just for the drama.

We can't forget Ezekiel Goodman as Dylan. The resident nice guy. Too nice, maybe? Someone get him a personality injection stat.

And finally, Ashley Moore as Riley. She brought a groundedness to the whole crazy situation. Someone had to be the voice of reason, even if nobody listened.

Supporting Players (Who Deserve Recognition!)

Now, onto the supporting cast, because let's be real, they made the show. Sebastian Amoruso as Johnny was... interesting. That's putting it nicely. He was that guy you loved to hate.

Bill Heck played Bruce, the dad with secrets. Heck definitely delivered the creepy dad vibes. Did anyone actually trust him? I certainly didn't.

And Brooke Bloom as Clara? Now there was a character. She felt straight out of a horror movie from the 80s. Someone give her an award for best unsettling cult leader portrayal.

Casting Choices: Hits and Misses?

Here's the thing. The casting wasn't bad. It was... interesting. Each actor brought something unique to the table.

But did they always fit the roles perfectly? That's where things get debatable. Some characters just didn't land the way they were intended.

For example, Spencer Sutherland as Quinn. I honestly forgot he was even in the show half the time. Sorry, Spencer!

The Killer's Identity (No Spoilers, Promise!)

The killer's reveal was... well, let's just say it was a choice. Did it make sense? Debatable. Did it elicit a reaction? Absolutely!

Unpopular opinion time: I kind of wish they'd gone in a completely different direction. Maybe frame the dog? Just kidding (mostly).

Ultimately, the cast of I Know What You Did Last Summer delivered. They gave us teen angst, questionable decisions, and plenty of screaming. What more could you want?

Whether you loved it or hated it, you can't deny that each actor brought their own brand of chaos to this crazy slasher series. And for that, we salute them.

So, grab some popcorn, rewatch the show, and let the debate begin! Which cast member was your favorite? And who deserved a better storyline?