Brooklyn Nine Nine I Want It That Way Episode Number
Picture this: five suspects, a brutal murder, and the only clue? A spontaneous, off-key rendition of the Backstreet Boys' biggest hit. This is the glorious absurdity that is the "I Want It That Way" episode of Brooklyn Nine-Nine.
It's Season 5, Episode 13. And it's a masterclass in comedic timing and unexpected character connections.
The Lineup Heard 'Round the World
The core of the episode revolves around a police lineup unlike any other. Jake Peralta, ever the pop culture enthusiast, uses the Backstreet Boys' classic to jog the memory of a witness who only remembers hearing the song during the crime.
Must Read
What ensues is pure comedic gold. Each suspect is forced to belt out a line from "I Want It That Way," revealing not just their (lack of) singing talent, but also slivers of their personality.
Why "I Want It That Way" Works So Well
The genius lies in the song's universal appeal. Everyone knows it, even if they pretend not to. This shared cultural touchstone instantly creates a connection with the audience, drawing them into the silliness.
Furthermore, the contrast between the serious nature of a murder investigation and the lighthearted, nostalgic vibe of a boy band anthem is hilarious. It's the perfect embodiment of Brooklyn Nine-Nine's signature blend of crime and comedy.
Beyond the Backstreet Boys: Character Moments
While the lineup scene is undoubtedly the highlight, the episode shines because it also offers sweet moments for our favorite characters.
Jake Peralta, as always, is in his element, reveling in his pop culture knowledge and using it (arguably effectively) to solve the case. His enthusiasm is infectious.
"Tell me why!" - A line that solves crimes.
Rosa Diaz, the tough-as-nails detective, is surprisingly affected by the song, showing a rare glimpse of vulnerability. It's a subtle but effective reminder that even the most stoic characters have their softer sides.
Even Captain Raymond Holt, known for his deadpan delivery, gets in on the fun. His stoic pronouncements about the Backstreet Boys add to the episode's overall charm.
The other squad members also contribute to the humor, making sure that the viewers feel like they are a part of the squad.
A Case of the Mondays... Made Better
The "I Want It That Way" episode is more than just a funny sketch. It's a well-crafted story that showcases the strengths of Brooklyn Nine-Nine: its ensemble cast, its quirky humor, and its ability to find heart in the most unexpected places.
It's a reminder that even in the face of serious crime, there's always room for a little levity and a whole lot of singing (badly). So, the next time you're feeling down, pop on this episode, sing along to "I Want It That Way," and let the 99th precinct brighten your day.
No doubt, this is the episode that can get stuck in your head even after many years.
