Brooklyn 99 I Want It That Way Cast
Okay, picture this: you're watching Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Suddenly, a crime scene gets interrupted by a suspect lineup and an impromptu rendition of the Backstreet Boys' "I Want It That Way." Pure comedic gold, right?
But have you ever stopped to think about the behind-the-scenes story of this iconic scene? Let’s take a look.
The Origin Story of the Interrogation
The "I Want It That Way" scene wasn't just some random idea. It stemmed from a real-life police technique. Believe it or not, cops actually do sometimes ask suspects to speak to compare their voices!
Must Read
The writers, brilliant as they are, took this mundane fact and cranked it up to eleven. They tossed in a boy band classic and the rest, as they say, is comedy history.
Casting the Culprits (and Singers!)
Finding the right actors for the lineup was crucial. They needed guys who could look believably suspicious and, well, at least hold a tune. Luckily, they nailed it.
It is funny how serious they are taking the singing. They are so nervous to be involved in this case.

Andre Braugher's Deadpan Delivery
Andre Braugher, as Captain Holt, is the master of deadpan. His complete lack of enthusiasm while participating in the singalong is what makes the scene even more hilarious.
Imagine him practicing "I Want It That Way" in his dressing room with complete seriousness. It is a funny image to imagine.
Andy Samberg: The Ring Leader
Of course, Andy Samberg (Jake Peralta) is the one who initiates the whole thing. His over-the-top enthusiasm and off-key singing are infectious. Jake has a knack for making the most out of any awkward situation.

It is hard not to laugh at the silliness of the whole thing. Jake's character is really the glue that held the comedy together.
The Power of a Pop Song
Why "I Want It That Way"? It is a universal song. Most people know at least a few lines, making it instantly relatable and hilarious. It is a great song to sing on a car ride or at karaoke.
Plus, the song's somewhat generic lyrics add to the absurdity. Asking potentially dangerous criminals to sing about love is so ludicrous that is funny.

Beyond the Laughs: A Touch of Heart
While primarily comedic, the scene has a surprising amount of heart. The shared moment of singing brings the characters together, highlighting the camaraderie within the precinct.
You can see how they all have a close friendship. They are more like a family and that connection adds to the show. It is also a funny break that happens within the crime of the case.
Even Holt, despite his stoicism, seems to subtly enjoy the moment. It is a brief glimpse into his humanity that makes him so endearing. It's a moment where you think maybe Holt isn't a robot after all.

The Legacy of the Lineup
The "I Want It That Way" scene isn't just a funny moment; it is a cultural phenomenon. It has been parodied, referenced, and re-enacted countless times.
It cemented Brooklyn Nine-Nine as a sitcom classic. It is a moment that fans will remember and love for years to come.
So, the next time you hear "I Want It That Way," remember the 99th precinct and their unique approach to police work. And maybe, just maybe, start your own impromptu singalong.
