American Horror Story Season 2 Episode 11 Cast

Okay, let's talk American Horror Story: Asylum. Specifically, Season 2, Episode 11. We all watched it, right? Good.

This isn't a deep dive. No film school jargon here. Just some thoughts on the cast of "Spilt Milk." Prepare for potentially controversial opinions!

The Usual Suspects (and My Love-Hate Relationship With Them)

Jessica Lange as Sister Jude

First off, Jessica Lange. Do we even need to say anything? She’s phenomenal. But honestly, sometimes Sister Jude annoyed me. I know, I know! Blasphemy!

Her character arc was wild. One minute she's a monster, the next a sympathetic victim. Maybe that’s why I was conflicted?

Is it just me or did anyone else scream at the TV, "Just get it together, Jude!"?

Zachary Quinto as Dr. Thredson

Then there’s Zachary Quinto as Dr. Oliver Thredson. Creepy doesn’t even begin to cover it. Seriously, I needed therapy after some of those scenes.

He played the perfect psychopath. That quiet, unsettling demeanor? Chills. Full stop.

But here's my hot take: he was almost too good. I kind of wanted him off screen sometimes. My poor nerves!

Sarah Paulson as Lana Winters

Ah, Sarah Paulson as Lana Winters. A true survivor. She went through absolute hell.

She was smart, resourceful, and determined. I definitely rooted for her. Every. Single. Time.

That said, did anyone else find her ending slightly... unsatisfying? Maybe I wanted more revenge? Or maybe I just wanted her to be happy ever after.

The Supporting Players (Who Deserve More Love)

Lily Rabe as Sister Mary Eunice

Okay, can we talk about Lily Rabe? Her portrayal of Sister Mary Eunice was terrifying and heartbreaking.

Possessed by the Devil? Check. Innocent and naive? Also check. The range! Someone give her all the awards.

I honestly felt bad for her... even when she was being super evil. Is that weird?

Evan Peters as Kit Walker

And then there's Evan Peters as Kit Walker. The wrongly accused, possibly alien-abducted Kit. Poor guy!

He played the innocence and confusion really well. I was always on his side, even when things got… strange.

Honestly, I think he was one of the only truly good people in that whole asylum. Though the aliens part? Still a bit confusing to me.

Joseph Fiennes as Monsignor Timothy Howard

Let's not forget Joseph Fiennes as Monsignor Timothy Howard. The morally ambiguous, ambitious clergyman.

He was a fascinating character. You never quite knew where he stood. Was he good? Bad? Just trying to survive?

I think he got off too easily, frankly. Someone needed to hold him accountable.

The Verdict: A Chaotic, But Brilliant Cast

The cast of American Horror Story: Asylum, especially in "Spilt Milk," was a masterpiece of acting. Even if some of the characters drove me absolutely bonkers.

They brought so much depth and complexity to those roles. It's why we're still talking about it years later.

So, unpopular opinion: Some of these characters were annoying, but the actors? Absolutely incredible. Agreed? (Please say yes.)